# Astra: confirming review of tenant-directory fix 5

Your round 3 (`CODEX-REVIEW-REGION-HA-TENANT-DIR-3.md`) found one P2: an inherited over-limit manifest entry trapped publishing in a permanent retry loop.

Fix 5 (318519f5) answers it:
- `hostfiles.Open` refuses a manifest that holds a path over 4095 bytes, with a terminal `ErrTooDeep`.
- `Run` stops on such a commit with one log line, without retrying.
- Restore, ValidateManifest and CopyManifest also refuse that manifest.
- Nothing is committed over it.

**Judge:**
1. Is the P2 closed?
2. Is the tenant-directory work (dca370c2..318519f5) now ready to merge dormant, with #279 as an activation gate?
3. Is anything new introduced?

Give findings P1/P2/P3 with file:line, then a verdict.